Reason Magazine

Site Search

Zoned Out

Taking the Amish to court.

As family farming loses its allure both socially and economically, the Amish of Huntsburg Township, Ohio, have turned to their woodworking skills to generate income. It's work that allows entire families to share in the enterprise and still maintain their core low-tech beliefs.

Enter Huntsburg's zoning laws. Township rules say home-based woodworking shops cannot exceed 1,000 square feet of floor space. The Amish quickly realized this was not big enough for a full-time woodworking business and tried to get exemptions for shops of 4,000 square feet.

Local planners would have none of it, though no residents of the town actually objected to the larger shops. Officials have hid behind legalese, and so the Amish have reluctantly turned to petition drives and court challenges--just the kind of engagement with the modern world they were trying to avoid by seeking traditional work.

"That's not the Amish way of life," Nathaniel Byler, one of the leaders of the anti-zoning Amish, told the Associated Press. "There's three words that I don't like: court, suing, judge. It's not scriptural to sue someone." 

Help Reason celebrate its next 40 years. Donate Now!
Send this article to:

More Articles by Jeff Taylor

  • Banking on Big Changes
    Will the next president will use the U.S. Treasury to refloat lending? Signs point to yes. (8/28)
  • Penalty Strokes
    Why does Dara Torres swim under a cloud? (7/31)
  • What Price Justice?
    Linked to the 2001 anthrax attacks, Steven Hatfill has finally had his day in court. (7/3)

Related Stories (Religion, Property Rights)

Latest Articles on Reason Online