Reason Magazine

Site Search

Data: Don't Ask, Just Spend

Complete print edition now available in digital version on NewsStand.com

"Don't ask, don't tell" isn't just a controversial military policy; it's an expensive one too. The Government Accountability Office estimates that the Defense Department has spent $95 million recruiting men and women to replace the 9,488 gays and lesbians chucked out of the service during the last 10 years--and that doesn't include the costs of inquiries, investigations, counseling, and discharge reviews, or the millions spent training the new recruits.

Pentagon brass have said gay personnel would complicate missions, but tossing out 322 enlistees with skills in important languages, including Arabic and Farsi, might create some complications as well. And the incidents that have most frequently prompted dismissal do not suggest that a gay-friendly military would be a sex-crazed one: 83 percent of the recruits  shown the door simply admitted they were homosexual, as opposed to attempting to engage in sexual activity.

In March 53 members of the House introduced a bill to repeal "don't ask, don't tell" and allow homosexual service members to serve openly, as they do in the ranks of America's closest ally, Britain. As Patrick Guerriero, president of the Log Cabin Republicans, put it, "we need people who can shoot straight, not necessarily who are straight."

Graph (not available online): Cost of Replacing Homosexual Armed Forces (in millions)

Help Reason celebrate its next 40 years. Donate Now!
Send this article to:

More Articles by Kerry Howley

  • Talk of the Town
    Free speech in Philly (11/1)
  • The One-Man Wall
    How a single Arizona legislator's obsession has changed immigration policy for the worse (9/22)
  • Get in Line!
    Will Americans have to prove their right to work via an error-plagued database? (9/18)

Related Stories (Government Spending, Gay/Lesbian Issues)

  • Obama's Numbers
    The president-elect has promised to make his math add up. Therein lies a glimmer of possibility. Matt Welch (12/1)
  • Lone Star Lessons
    What Texas and Florida can teach big spending states Leonard Gilroy (11/26)
  • What's the Matter With Libertarians?
    Thomas Frank blames the freedom movement for Jack Abramoff and George W. Bush Jesse Walker (11/20)

Latest Articles on Reason Online